If I start with explanation of “Comfort Women”, it would be a long story. So let me skip it. So many Asian women, most of them were Koreans, Chinese, and Japanese, too, had suffered from Japanese Imperial Forces’ sex exploitation system since Sino-Japan War and during World War Two. For this issue, a women activist group “Violence Against Women in War-Network Japan(VAWWNet Japan)” held “The Women’s International War Crimes Tribunal on Japan’s Military Sexual Slavery” in 2000. They say in their web site
“The Women’s International War Crimes Tribunal on Japan’s Military Sexual Slavery” (the Women’s Tribunal) was a people’s tribunal organized by Asian women and human rights organizations and supported by international NGOs. It was set up to adjudicate Japan’s military sexual violence, in particular the enslavement of “comfort women,” to bring those responsible for it to justice, and to end the ongoing cycle of impunity for wartime sexual violence against women.
At that time, Japan’s state-run broadcasting cooperation NHK covered the story of the Women’s Tribunal with interviewing VAWWNet Japan and some victims of the sexual slavery. But just right before the on-air, the program “ETV2000; How war should be judged?” which was the coverage of the Women’s Tribunal was changed its contents by pressure of two high rank politicians. It is unforgivable by any means that a public broadcasting accepts politicians’ pressure and bents their reports by that. Isn’t Japan a country that freedom of expression is guaranteed? It is to be shamed but one of the politicians, Shizo Abe, became prime minister of Japan. He threatened guys of NHK and demanded that the program should be changed. And when he was the prime minister, what he did was just escalating conflicts with North Korea and in turn making it difficult to settle the abduction issue. He was so irresponsible that he suddenly threw his job away.
VAWWnet Japan sued NHK in order to clarify the reason why the program was distorted to underestimate the significance of the tribunal, and to recover the damage. The final decision handed by the Supreme Court recently was quite surprising and terrible, which dismisses the high court decision demanding NHK to pay compensation. It also rejected the appeal that interviewees’ expectation should be kept. The decision by Chief Justice Ms. Kazuko Yoko’o was enough to make me doubt the quality of jurisdiction of Japan. Oops, I think foreword of today’s post has already been long, but what I want to write is starting from here.
VAWWnet Japan got an e-mail on June 13th, it’s around 4p.m.. The e-mail address indicated that it was sent from a news paper company “Nihon Keizai Shimbun (Nikkei)”. Although I know that my English is not enough to translate the e-mail especially to express how the words in the mail are rough, but let me try it.
No way for media to yield interviewee’s expectation.
Have a common sense, Stupid. It’s the role of media to report neutrally even what the interviewees don’t like. Why should the public broadcasting release you guys’ extreme ideology? No-brainers. You guys’ lack of common sense is absolutely hopeless.
Nikkei Shimbun made an oral apologize on June 24th, but did neither show the name of the sender nor how retribution was made for him in the company. To me, what this Nikkei guy said is quite amazing. His common sense is non-sense for the people. I mean if you overview this issue between VAWWnet Japan and NHK, which is involved with far right politicians who want distort the reality in history, how mass media should deal with the issue is very simple. Obeying strong power, insulting victims, and cheating ordinary Japanese people? NO. It should be opposite. Mass media should reject suppression from politicians and government and should try to show people what happened especially in the situation that wrongdoing of the government resulted in huge damage on people.
I don’t say that a person should not send an e-mail to tell his/her personal opinion by using company’s e-mail account. And sometimes it should be allowed for an interviewer to use the materials of an interviewee in different ways that do not follow the expectation of interviewees, for example, like the case of the sword craftsman in the movie “Yasukuni”. But as a result, what he did was insulting ex-comfort women and allowing freedom for the power to intervene mass media.
A blogger, Mr. Hiroyuki Ida says “This level of guy works in mass media, who pave the way for war”. I agree with him. I guess that sometimes news coverage on economy says Nikkei Index or Nikkei Average with Topix for stock market in Japan. I think it will soon be taken place by Shanghai Index or some. But anyways, would you please remember today’s post; what a person who works in Nikkei did.
Any mistranslations or misunderstandings, if there were, they should be aiueo5’s responsibilities, not the quoted materials and its authors. And at last, the sender of the message from VAWWnetJapan welcomes forwarding. So I just extract and put the whole of e-mail from a worker in Nihon Keizai Shimbun. The souce is Mr. Hiroyuki Ida’s blog.
——- following a quotation of the e-mail ——————
『 取材先の「期待」に報道が従うわけないだろ。
常識を持て。ばか者。報道ってのは取材先の嫌なこともちゃんと中立的に
伝えるのが役目なんだよ。なんであなたがたの偏向したイデオロギーを公共の
電波が垂れ流さなきゃいけないんだよ。あほか。
あんたがたの常識のなさにはあきれはてる。 』
——- the end of quote ———————————